Likely Safe High confidence

Once Again Organic Creamy Peanut Butter No Sugar Added (Single Ingredient, Unsalted) - Gluten-Free, No Palm Oil, 16 oz

Once Again ★★★★☆ 4.5 · 1,112 reviews

Labeled gluten-free with a single-ingredient formula (organic peanuts). No gluten-containing ingredients are listed, and the product is gluten-free in labeling, though no third-party certification is evidenced.

🌾 Gluten-free labeled Non-GMO Organic ⚠ No 3rd-party cert
$12.51
Buy on Amazon →

As an Amazon Associate, Gluto earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability may change.

Celiac verdict
Likely safe
Confidence
High
Type
Nut butters & spreads
Size
16 ounce (pack of 1)
Price tier
Mid
Read
5 min
✅ Why it works
  • Single-ingredient, organic peanuts only
  • Gluten-free labeling
  • No palm oil
  • No sugar added / unsweetened
  • Glass jar packaging
  • Organic and non-GMO status supported by data
⚠ Keep in mind
  • Higher price per ounce compared to some mainstream peanut butters
  • Texture reported as runnier by some buyers
  • No explicit third-party gluten-free certification evidenced

Gluten safety details

Labeled gluten-free
Yes
Certifications
None documented
Ingredient risks
Peanuts only; no added gluten-containing ingredients listed.
Cross-contact notes
Not specified in the supplied data; no cross-contact/disclaimer details provided.

Labeled gluten-free with a single-ingredient formula (organic peanuts). No gluten-containing ingredients are listed, and the product is gluten-free in labeling, though no third-party certification is evidenced.

Cross-contact details are not provided; verify current packaging and labeling.

What to expect

A 16 oz glass jar of creamy peanut butter made from organic peanuts only, with no salt or sugar added, no palm oil, and a gluten-free, non-GMO label. Expect a very simple ingredient list, potential variability in spread consistency (creamy but sometimes runnier), and a price around $12.50 per jar with a typical positive rating from buyers.

👍 Best for
  • gluten-free diets seeking a single-ingredient, unsweetened peanut butter
  • organic, non-GMO food choices
  • consumers avoiding palm oil
👎 Not ideal for
  • budget-conscious shoppers seeking lower-cost peanut butter
  • buyers who want a thick, very sticky texture (given occasional runnier texture)
  • shoppers requiring formal third-party gluten-free certifications

The full guide

Product snapshot

Once Again Organic Creamy Peanut Butter No Sugar Added is a single-ingredient product made from organic peanuts. It is unsalted, contains no added sugar, and uses no palm oil. The product is labeled gluten-free and non-GMO, and it is packaged in a glass jar.

Taste, texture, and uses

Recipes and everyday use rely on a very simple ingredient list: organic peanuts only. Many buyers highlight a pure peanut flavor and creamy texture, though some note the spread can be runnier than expected. The absence of salt and sugar means it behaves differently in some applications (e.g., baking or pairing with sweet toppings) compared to salted, sweetened varieties. It lends itself to spreading on bread, stirring into smoothies, or using in recipes that benefit from a neutral, peanut-forward component.

Gluten safety and labeling

The product is labeled gluten-free and uses a single-ingredient formula (organic peanuts). There is no explicit evidence of third-party gluten-free certification in the provided data. Cross-contact details are not specified. Based on the listing, celiac-friendly labeling is likely, but consumers may wish to verify current packaging for any updates.

Value, packaging, and suitability

The 16 oz jar is priced around $12.51, placing it in a mid-range price tier. Packaging in a glass jar is noted as a value-add by some buyers. This product is best for gluten-free diets that want a true single-ingredient, unsweetened peanut butter and for those prioritizing organic and non-GMO claims. It may be less ideal for budget-conscious shoppers or for those seeking a thicker, biteier texture or formal third-party certifications.

What shoppers say

💚 People liked

⚠ People flagged

Some reviewers find the consistency too runny; value-for-money opinions are mixed.
Higher price relative to other peanut butters.

Key takeaways

  • Choose for a true single-ingredient, organic peanut butter with no sugar or salt.
  • Expect a gluten-free label, but note the lack of explicit third-party gluten-free certification.
  • Be prepared for a possibly runnier spread and a higher price point.
  • Glass jar packaging may appeal to those valuing packaging quality.
How we assess this: Gluto summarizes manufacturer labeling, listing data, and community signals — it is not a medical guarantee. Always read the current label and confirm with the manufacturer before purchase, especially for celiac disease.

Evidence gaps for this product:
  • No explicit third-party gluten-free certification is evidenced in the provided data.
  • Cross-contact or shared facility details are not provided.
  • No packaging-labeled certification information beyond gluten-free and organic in listing text.
Likely Safe Once Again Organic Creamy Peanut Butter No Sugar Added (Single Ingredient, Unsalted) - Gluten-Free, No Palm Oil, 16 oz $12.51
Buy on Amazon →