Celiac safety profile
Everlys Ice Cream
Ice Cream Shop
3108 6 Mile Rd, Caledonia, WI 53402
What you can eat here
Pulled from Gluto's celiac safety report for this location.
✅ Reported safe options
- Gluten-free cones (waffle cones)
- Gluten-free cones (waffle cups)
- Gluten-free brownies
- Gluten-free cookies
- Gluten-free cake
- Gluten-free muffins
⚠️ Risks & cross-contamination
- Not a dedicated gluten-free facility, so cross-contamination risk can exist despite precautions.
- While many staff are described as knowledgeable and careful (glove changes, dedicated scooping practices, separate plates and bowls for GF when requested), there are reports indicating gaps on some days (e.g., GF cones unavailable).
- Location inside a gas station setting may influence perceived safety and consistency of precautions.
Gluto score breakdown
Each axis is scored 0–100 from research + community signals.