Celiac safety profile
Keys Chocolates & Ice Cream
Ice Cream Shop
81933 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
What you can eat here
Pulled from Gluto's celiac safety report for this location.
✅ Reported safe options
- Gluten-free key lime pie on a stick
- Gluten-free whole key lime pie
- Gluten-free ice cream (with gluten-free cones when available)
- Gluten-free chocolate-dipped key lime pie popsicles
- Gluten-free sorbet
- Gluten-free chocolate-covered gluten-free Oreos
⚠️ Risks & cross-contamination
- The facility is not dedicated gluten-free, which means cross-contamination is a possibility.
- Availability of gluten-free cones can be inconsistent, potentially affecting safe options during a visit.
- While some staff offer allergen guidance and safety protocols, there are reports of variability in how clearly gluten-free information is communicated.
Gluto score breakdown
Each axis is scored 0–100 from research + community signals.